When Hope Keeps You Stuck: Childhood Trauma and the Need to Be Chosen
Hope is generally considered a good thing. We encourage people to hold on to it, especially during difficult times. And sometimes hope is exactly what keeps us going.
But I've been thinking about what happens when hope keeps us invested in situations that aren't changing.
Maybe you're hoping your partner will become more emotionally available. Maybe you're waiting for a parent to acknowledge the ways they hurt you. Or perhaps you're holding on to a relationship because you remember how wonderful it was in the beginning.
You can spend years waiting for something to change without realizing how much that waiting is costing you.
How Childhood Emotional Neglect Shapes Hope
If you grew up with childhood emotional neglect, hope may have been an important way of coping.
Children have very little control over their circumstances. When adults are unavailable, unpredictable, or unable to provide protection, imagining that things will eventually improve can help a child endure what's happening.
But what happens when we carry that same approach into adulthood?
We may continue hoping that someone will eventually become the person we need them to be. We tolerate disappointment, explain away behavior, and focus on someone's potential rather than what they're consistently showing us.
I recently wrote about my own experience with this in The Magic in Me: How I Stopped Waiting to Be Saved, published by Tiny Buddha.
What I've been examining since then is how easily hope can become a substitute for accepting something painful.
Sometimes the reason we keep hoping isn't that we have good reason to believe things will change. It's that accepting they might not change brings up feelings we don't want to experience.
When Hope Becomes Avoidance
I've started referring to this pattern as toxic hope.
It's not the same as optimism. It's what happens when our investment in a particular outcome prevents us from responding to what's actually happening.
Consider someone whose partner repeatedly promises to change but never follows through. Each apology brings relief and another opportunity to believe the relationship will improve.
The person may genuinely love their partner. They may also be deeply invested in the relationship becoming something it has never consistently been.
The distinction matters because wanting someone to change isn't evidence that they will.
For people with histories of childhood emotional neglect or inconsistent caregiving, letting go of that hope can be especially painful. It may mean confronting the familiar experience of wanting something important from someone who cannot or will not provide it.
This can also contribute to codependency. Instead of deciding what we need and whether a relationship meets those needs, we become preoccupied with figuring out how to get the other person to change.
Why Understanding the Pattern Isn't Always Enough
I've understood my own childhood and relationship patterns for years. I know how I learned to fawn, why I looked for protection through relationships, and how much being wanted mattered to me.
But understanding those patterns hasn't always stopped me from repeating them.
During a recent Brainspotting session, I recognized how frequently I reached for hope when I was experiencing sadness or longing.
As soon as something hurt, I started imagining how it might get better. I was so accustomed to looking for another possibility that I rarely stayed with the disappointment long enough to understand what I was feeling.
When I stopped searching for reassurance, I found grief.
I was grieving the years I'd spent wanting to feel loved and protected, and how often I'd looked outside myself for someone to finally meet those needs.
This is an important distinction in trauma work. Recognizing a pattern doesn't necessarily resolve the feelings driving it. Sometimes we have to experience the sadness, anger, or disappointment we've been trying to avoid.
We may know perfectly well that someone isn't meeting our needs and still struggle to accept it.
How to Tell Whether Hope Is Keeping You Stuck
If you're struggling to let go of a relationship, expectation, or imagined future, consider these questions:
What am I hoping will happen? Be specific. Are you waiting for an apology, consistent affection, accountability, or a commitment?
What evidence do I have that things are changing? Look at behavior over time rather than promises, explanations, or occasional improvements.
What am I tolerating while I wait? Consider what the situation is costing you emotionally and what needs you're neglecting.
What would I do if I knew nothing was going to change? You don't have to assume that nothing will change. The question helps you recognize decisions you may have been postponing.
The goal isn't to eliminate hope or force yourself to make an immediate decision. It's to consider whether you're making choices based on the relationship or situation you actually have.
You can care about someone, want things to improve, and still establish boundaries around what you're willing to accept.
What Happens When You Stop Waiting?
One of the questions I've been asking myself lately is what I want my life to look like when being wanted is no longer such a central concern.
I'm fifty-one. I've spent enough of my life preoccupied with relationships and trying to find the security I didn't have growing up.
Lately I've been paying more attention to what I enjoy, what I need, and how I actually want to spend my time.
Some of that has been surprisingly ordinary. Taking a bath in the middle of the day. Spending time with my animals. Writing because I enjoy it. Resting without feeling that I need to earn it.
I've spent years prioritizing what I thought I should do so that something better might happen later.
I'm trying something different.
I still believe in hope. I still value spirituality, imagination, and the possibility that life can surprise me.
But I don't want to keep putting my life on hold while waiting for something or someone else to make it better.
That's the distinction I'm learning to make: I can hope things improve while also making decisions about the life I have now.
Therapy for Childhood Emotional Neglect and Codependency
If you repeatedly find yourself waiting for someone to change, struggling to establish boundaries, or understanding unhealthy relationship patterns without being able to change them, therapy can help you explore what's keeping those patterns in place.
I'm Allison Briggs, an Austin-based Licensed Professional Counselor specializing in childhood trauma, emotional neglect, and codependency. I use Brainspotting, EMDR, and IFS-informed therapy to work with the emotional experiences underlying these patterns.
I offer in-person therapy in Austin and virtual therapy throughout Texas. Learn more about working with me or schedule a free 15-minute consultation.
On Being Real
I've been thinking about writing this book since I was six years old. The manuscript keeps evolving, the subtitle is still a mystery, and I'm determined to find the right publisher.
Could it take years? Maybe. Am I giving up? No way. This little train is going to keep chugging.
Want to know when On Being Real is finally published? Sign up below!
Can't wait for the book?
Read my writing on trauma, relationships, and the sometimes ridiculous business of being human.
Want blog updates in your inbox? Visit my blog and scroll to the bottom of the page to find the Mailchimp signup.
✍️ Read My Blog & SubscribeThanks for following along. — Allison